Introduction
As we enter the era of ubiquitous connectivity and data-centric computing, the demand for high-performance, energy-efficient data communication and processing systems is skyrocketing. Silicon photonics (SiPho) has emerged as a promising technology to address this demand, enabling the realization of high-bandwidth, low-power optical interconnects and on-chip optical signal processing. However, despite the rapid progress in SiPho, fully integrated electronic-photonic systems-on-chip remain elusive due to the limitations of the monolithic SiPho platform [1].
SiPho Integration Platforms and Applications
Several foundries now offer SiPho platforms, but most focus solely on pure silicon photonics, without monolithically integrated electronics or lasers. A typical SiPho platform comprises a silicon-on-insulator (SOI) substrate, featuring silicon waveguides and other passive photonic components, along with germanium photodetectors and optional modulators, as shown in Figure 1.
While originally developed for optical transceiver products operating at 1.3-1.55μm wavelengths and high baudrates (50-100GBaud), SiPho platforms are finding applications in diverse domains beyond telecommunications. These include sensing (LiDAR, laser Doppler vibrometry), healthcare (optical coherence tomography, photoacoustic imaging, neural probes), augmented/virtual reality, photonic interposers for artificial intelligence chips, and photonic quantum computing, among others. Many of these emerging applications do not necessarily leverage the high-speed capabilities of SiPho platforms and may operate at wavelengths outside the 1.3-1.55μm range.
Limitations of Monolithic SiPho and the Need for Heterogeneous Integration
Despite their impressive capabilities, monolithic SiPho platforms lack several key building blocks for fully integrated photonic systems-on-chip. These missing components include efficient light sources (lasers), electro-optic modulators, optical isolators/circulators, and specialized photodetectors, among others. Integrating these essential devices monolithically on a SiPho platform is challenging due to the material constraints of silicon.
Many of these missing components are based on III-V semiconductors (e.g., GaN, GaAs, InP, GaSb) or thin-film materials (e.g., lithium niobate, barium titanate, cerium-doped yttrium iron garnet), which often incorporate non-CMOS-compatible elements like gold or lithium. Consequently, heterogeneous integration – the co-integration of multiple material systems on a single chip – has emerged as a crucial enabler for realizing high-performance, highly integrated electronic-photonic circuits.
Heterogeneous Integration Technologies
Several approaches have been explored for heterogeneous integration of SiPho with non-native devices, each with its own advantages and trade-offs:
1. Micro-optic bench: In this approach, discrete components (e.g., lasers, modulators) are assembled onto a SiPho chip using active alignment and hermetic sealing techniques. While offering flexibility, this method suffers from high unit and assembly costs, making it less suitable for high-volume applications.
2. Flip-chip integration: This back-end integration technique involves flipping and bonding prefabricated dies (known good dies) onto a SiPho chip using passive alignment techniques. While more cost-effective than micro-optic benches, flip-chip integration still involves sequential integration, leading to relatively high costs. It also lacks native hermetic sealing.
3. Wafer bonding and wafer reconstitution: In this middle-of-line integration approach, entire wafers are bonded together using precise lithographic alignment. However, this technique imposes constraints on die size and requires critical surface preparation. Furthermore, it does not allow for known good die selection.
4. Hetero-epitaxial growth: This front-end integration method involves the direct growth of non-silicon materials (e.g., III-Vs) on a silicon substrate. While potentially offering monolithic integration, hetero-epitaxial growth faces significant challenges, including lattice constant mismatch, interface polarity issues, and thermal expansion coefficient mismatch. It also suffers from reliability and process integration concerns, limiting its versatility.
Micro-Transfer Printing: A Versatile Heterogeneous Integration Solution
Among the various heterogeneous integration technologies, micro-transfer printing (MTP) has emerged as a particularly promising and versatile approach for realizing advanced electronic-photonic integrated circuits. MTP combines the advantages of flip-chip integration (known good die selection, back-end integration) and wafer bonding (high throughput, efficient coupling) while mitigating their respective drawbacks.
MTP Technology Deep-Dive
At its core, MTP involves the transfer of released, micron-scale semiconductor chiplets (also known as micro-devices or micro-components) from their native substrate to a silicon target wafer using an elastomeric stamp, as illustrated in Figure 6. The transfer process leverages the viscoelastic properties of polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) stamps, which are structured to selectively pick up and print the chiplets.
The MTP process flow typically involves the following steps:
Chiplet fabrication and release: The chiplets (e.g., III-V lasers, modulators, photodetectors) are fabricated on their native substrate using standard processes. A sacrificial release layer is then undercut, allowing the chiplets to be released from the substrate.
Stamp preparation: PDMS stamps with a specific post layout are fabricated to match the chiplet array on the source wafer. The stamp posts are designed to conform to the viscoelastic properties of PDMS, ensuring reliable pick-up and printing of the chiplets.
Pick-up: The PDMS stamp is brought into conformal contact with the released chiplets, allowing them to adhere to the stamp posts through van der Waals forces.
Printing: The chiplet-laden stamp is then aligned to the target SiPho wafer using advanced pattern recognition and alignment systems. The chiplets are printed onto the target wafer by bringing the stamp into contact and applying a controlled shear-force.
Integration: After printing, the chiplets are encapsulated and electrically interconnected using standard back-end-of-line (BEOL) processes, such as adhesive bonding, dielectric deposition, and metallization.
This massively parallel printing process enables the dense co-integration of diverse chiplet types (e.g., III-Vs, thin films, 2D materials) on a single SiPho target wafer with exceptional alignment accuracy (±0.5μm 3σ). Moreover, the transfer printing process decouples the fabrication of non-native devices from the SiPho platform, allowing for independent optimization of each component.
MTP is remarkably versatile, capable of integrating a wide range of material systems, including GaN, GaAs, InP, GaSb, lithium niobate, barium titanate, cerium-doped yttrium iron garnet, and 2D materials, among others. This versatility stems from the diverse release chemistries available for different materials, as summarized in Figure 9.
Demonstrations and Unique Selling Proposition
The potential of MTP for realizing advanced electronic-photonic integrated circuits has been demonstrated through several recent research accomplishments:
1. Integration of InP semiconductor optical amplifiers (SOAs) on a 400nm SOI platform, enabling high-power (25mW) C-band lasers and amplifiers (Figure 10).
2. Heterogeneous integration of O-band (1.31μm) InAs/GaAs quantum dot distributed feedback (DFB) lasers on SiPho, achieving high output powers (20mW) and excellent side-mode suppression ratios (60dB) (Figure 11).
3. Realization of extended cavity lasers by integrating InP gain chips with silicon waveguide Bragg gratings, enabling narrow linewidth operation (Figure 12).
4. Integration of high-performance uni-traveling carrier photodiodes (UTCs) with responsivities of 0.45A/W and bandwidths exceeding 100GHz (Figure 13).
5. Heterogeneous integration of 850nm vertical-cavity surface-emitting lasers (VCSELs) on silicon nitride (SiN) photonic integrated circuits (PICs), enabling single-mode, polarization-stable, and tunable operation (Figure 14).
6. Co-integration of lithium niobate (LiNbO3) electro-optic films on SiN PICs, achieving bandwidths exceeding 50GHz and potentially reaching 100GHz (Figure 15).
In addition to these photonic device demonstrations, MTP has been successfully applied to integrate electronic chiplets, such as CMOS drivers/receivers and digital electronics, onto SiPho platforms. This capability enables highly integrated, 3D electronic-photonic systems for applications like wafer-level optical interconnects, leveraging the advantages of thin chiplets, short interconnects, and ultra-low-loss SiN photonic interposers.
The unique selling proposition of MTP lies in its ability to combine the following key attributes:
Versatility in integrating diverse material systems and devices on a target substrate
High alignment accuracy (±0.5μm 3σ)
High throughput (e.g., 45 seconds per reticle comprising 20 chips)
Dense integration (1000s of devices per reticle)
High coupling efficiency (<0.5dB/interface)
Very low electrical parasitics (few fF/interconnect)
Placement of micron-thick and micron-scale footprint components
Moderately low cost in moderately high volumes
Outlook and Conclusions
As the demand for highly integrated electronic-photonic systems continues to grow across various application domains, micro-transfer printing has emerged as an enabling technology for wafer-scale heterogeneous integration. By allowing the co-integration of any material or device that can be released from its substrate onto a silicon photonics target wafer, MTP offers unparalleled versatility and performance.
While significant progress has been made in demonstrating the capabilities of MTP for advanced electronic-photonic circuits, several challenges remain to be addressed. These include establishing a robust supply chain, demonstrating high yield and reliability, and further optimizing the integration processes to fully exploit the potential of this disruptive technology.
Nonetheless, the unique attributes of MTP, coupled with the ever-increasing demand for highly integrated electronic-photonic systems, position this heterogeneous integration approach as a key enabler for realizing the next generation of highly integrated, high-performance, and energy-efficient data communication and processing systems.
Reference
[2] G. Roelkens, "Micro-transfer printing for heterogeneous electronic-photonic integrated circuits," in 2024 IEEE International Solid-State Circuits Conference (ISSCC) Forums, 2024.
Comments